The 2-Cent Club: Why Your Points Are Worthless Until You Burn Them Right

🎧 Always Turn Left: Stop Losing 6X Value | The Redemption Spread and Why Your Business Deserves Better

0:00

/1130.370612

1×

Most small business owners think they’re winning the game when they see a six-figure points balance.

The problem? They’re not.

Points are potential energy - they mean nothing until you convert them into value.

And that conversion rate (your burn) is where 80% of companies fail.

They earn decently, maybe 2-3 points per dollar across spend. But then they redeem at a measly 1¢ each. That’s not a travel hack. That’s cashback in disguise.

At UpNonStop, we call it The Redemption Spread - the multiplier between what you earn and what you burn. Because the same points can be worth 1% or 10%, depending entirely on how you use them.

Let’s break it down... 👇🏻

The Redemption Spectrum: 1¢ to 3.5¢ Per Point

Here’s how the same stash of points can swing from forgettable to phenomenal.

1¢ per point: The Lazy Cashout

This is what happens when your office manager redeems Chase points for “Pay Yourself Back” or statement credits.
At 1¢ per point, 100,000 points = $1,000.

It feels clean, safe, and immediate. But it’s financial malpractice if you’re earning those points strategically.

Let’s say you earned those points at 3 points per dollar on ad spend.
Your effective return: → 3 ppd × 1¢ = 3% back.

You’d get the same from a simple 3% cash-back card - no flights, no transfers, no fun.

1.5¢ per point: The Easy Redemption

Booking through a travel portal (Chase, Amex, Capital One) often gives you 1.25¢-1.5¢ per point.
Better, but not brilliant.
Now 100,000 points = $1,500.
If your earn rate was 3 ppd, your real return = 4.5%.

That’s acceptable, especially for domestic business travel. But it’s still leaving 30–50% of potential value unclaimed.

2¢ per point: The Entry to the 2-Cent Club

Now you’re doing something right.
This is typically a transfer partner sweet spot - United business class to Europe, Hyatt category 7 property, or a Singapore Airlines redemption at saver level.
At 2¢ per point, 100,000 points = $2,000.

If you earned 3 ppd?
Your return = 6%.
At 4 ppd? 8%.

Now you’re outperforming most investment portfolios with what was otherwise just business spending.

2.5¢ per point: The Smart Redemption

This is where UpNonStop clients live.
Business class to Asia, premium partner routes, SLH redemptions via Hyatt, ANA Round-the-World awards - the kind of stuff that feels impossible until it’s mapped out strategically.

100,000 points = $2,500.
At 3 ppd, that’s 7.5% back.
At 4 ppd, 10%.

Now we’re not talking perks. We’re talking yield.

3¢ per point: The Strategic Redemption

Few hit this consistently. But when you do, it changes your cost structure.
Example: 75,000 KrisFlyer miles for a $2,250 Singapore Airlines business ticket.
That’s exactly 3¢/pt.

If your earn rate was 4 ppd, you’re realizing a 12% return on spend.

This is where your corporate travel budget becomes a financial instrument - every $100K in card spend drives $12K in high-value travel return.

3.5¢ per point: The Unicorn Redemption

ANA Round-the-World. Lufthansa First. JAL Suites. Or a $5K Park Hyatt stay for 140K Hyatt points.
That’s 3.5¢/pt or higher.
Earn at 4 ppd → 14% return on spend.
Earn at 9.6 ppd (yes, our top client does) → 33.6% return.

The points aren’t the reward. The redemption strategy is.

Layering the Burn on the Earn

Now, let’s quantify how the two sides (earn and burn) multiply.

This table is the whole game.

If your company earns well but redeems poorly, you’re stuck in the bottom-left.
If you optimize both sides, you’re printing value from thin air.

Most UpNonStop clients start around 2-3 ppd earn and 1¢-1.2¢ burn.
That’s a 2-3% effective return.
Within 90 days, we lift that to 3-4 ppd and 2¢+ burn - now they’re hitting 6-8%.
By year two, we build a playbook that sustains 10%+ returns.

That’s not magic. It’s method.

Why Most Businesses Burn Badly

Because redemption is reactive.
Someone books a trip, sees a big balance, and decides, “let’s just use points.”

It feels smart - zero out-of-pocket travel. But in reality, that’s like selling your company stock the day before it splits.

Here’s why most burns fail:

1. They redeem through portals instead of partners.
   The portal guarantees convenience - and kills upside.
2. They mix currencies.
   A little Chase, a little Amex, some Delta SkyMiles. None of it aligned.
3. They don’t plan redemptions against forecasted travel.
   The most powerful way to burn efficiently is to pre-target trips 3-12 months out.
4. They assume value = cash saved.
   Wrong. Value = value per point earned.

Burning 100K points for a $1,000 domestic flight? That’s lazy yield.
Burning 100K points for a $4,000 business-class seat to Tokyo? That’s leverage.

The Math Behind the Madness

Let’s model $500K in annual business spend:

• 30% in ads (3X)
• 40% in operations (2X)
• 30% in travel & dining (4X)

That’s an average earn rate of 3 ppd → 1.5M points per year.

At different redemption rates:

• 1¢ → $15,000 travel value
• 2¢ → $30,000
• 3¢ → $45,000
• 3.5¢ → $52,500

Now imagine doing that across three years... That’s $157,500 in travel ROI - all from the same business spending you already do.

No gimmicks. Just better use of currency.

The Opportunity Cost of Mediocrity

Every time you cash out at 1¢, you’re forfeiting 50–70% of what those points could’ve delivered.

That’s like leaving $20,000 of travel ROI on the table every year - per $500K in spend.

Would you ignore a $20,000 tax deduction?
Would you throw away $20,000 of client value?

Then stop treating points like participation trophies.

The Redemption Hierarchy

Here’s how we classify burn value at UpNonStop:

If your company is still in “Smart” territory, you’re fine - but you’re playing defense.
The goal is to climb the hierarchy. Each jump adds 1-2% to your effective return on total spend.

How Airlines and Banks Profit (While You Don’t)

Airlines love your low redemption behavior.
When you burn at 1¢, they redeem your points cheaply and keep the float.
When you transfer to partners at 2-3¢, they lose some of that spread - which is exactly why those redemptions feel “hard to find.”

They want you trapped in the portal, spending more to save less.
That’s the business model.

UpNonStop flips it.

We engineer redemptions around partner valuations and open-inventory opportunities - where your point’s backend cost to the airline is lowest and your realized value is highest.

You win because you’re using the same ecosystem the pros use - not the one built for convenience.

The Real Play: Yield Management for Your Spend

When you start treating points as yield, not perks, everything changes.

Each card category becomes an asset class.
Each redemption becomes an exit event.

The same mindset airlines use to fill a plane efficiently, you apply to your own business spend.

• Earn side: maximize accrual rate per dollar.
• Burn side: maximize redemption yield per point.
• Bridge: forecast travel 3-12 months ahead so you can target the right currencies.

That’s not “travel hacking.”
That’s operational finance - with upgrades.

The 2-Cent Rule

Our rule for SMBs is simple:
Never burn below 2¢ unless it moves cashflow.

If redeeming today replaces a high-interest expense, fine. But otherwise, hold and aim higher.
Every burn should beat the 2¢ threshold or serve a strategic cash purpose.

Once you start thinking that way, you join what we call The 2-Cent Club - the owners who turn points from perks into profit centers.

Example: The Legal Firm Upgrade

One of our clients, a legal firm out of Pittsburgh, spends around $1.2M annually - mostly domestic travel.
They earn roughly 3.8 ppd across all cards.

Before UpNonStop:

• Redemption value: 1¢/pt (portal bookings).
• Effective return: 3.8%.

After optimization:

• Same points.
• New redemption mix averaging 2.6¢/pt.
• Effective return: 9.88%.

They now upgrade every attorney on cross-country flights using flexible bank points - no incremental cost.
The CFO calls it “our most painless margin expansion.”

The 10% Club Is Real

Most UpNonStop clients stabilize between 8-12% yield on spend after a full year.
That’s not because they spend more. It’s because they spend smarter and burn intentionally.

We’ve seen it across plumbers, design studios, IT firms, law practices - the math always holds.

The top 1% of redemptions hit 20%+.
The sweet spot is 10%.
Anything below 4%? You’re still flying coach in both seats - cash and points.

Final Approach

Airlines built the game. Banks made it profitable. You (the business owner) fund it.

Your job is to reverse-engineer it - earn where it pays, burn where it multiplies. Because in this system, you’re either the one collecting yield, or the one subsidizing it.

The 2-Cent Club isn’t about bragging rights. It’s about precision. It’s about every dollar you already spend returning like an investment.

You’ve done the hard part - you’re running the business.
Now make your spend fly just as high.