The Rewards Ponzi (And Why It Keeps Working)

🎧 Always Turn Left: Cracking the Code of Credit Card Rewards | Who Really Pays for Your Free Flights

0:00

/1732.208617

1×

The Map of the Machine

There’s a reason the rewards game feels like a casino where the drinks are free and the oxygen never runs out. Nobody in the room wants you to step outside and see the building from the street. Do that, and the blueprint is simple:

Merchants → Banks (Issuers) → Card Networks → Airlines/Hotels → Consumers

Merchants fund the pot. Banks deal the chips. Networks run the table. Airlines and hotels mint the prizes. Consumers - some savvy, many not - supply the drama. Every swipe moves money along this conveyor belt. Every point is a receipt for value that might exist later, if you’re patient, disciplined, and slightly obsessive.

The magic is not that points exist. The magic is that the system pays you in a currency it controls, on a timetable it sets, for an inventory it can quietly shrink or inflate at will. If that sounds like a Ponzi, it’s because the optics rhyme: more participants chasing paper promises whose real cost is deferred. But unlike a true Ponzi, there’s a real economic engine underneath: merchant fees, interest revenue, and the sale of miles to banks. The cash flows are real and immediate. The liabilities are also real - only slower and softer around the edges. That gap in timing is the house edge.

Follow the Money (and the Liability)

Let’s narrate a single $100 purchase at a boutique hotel gift shop.

1. Merchant → Issuer/Network: The shop takes your premium rewards card. Interchange and assessments come off the top. Round numbers: the merchant nets something like $97–$98 after all fees. They shrug and call it “cost of doing business.” It is also the seed capital for your next “free” vacation.
2. Issuer → You (Points): Your bank credits you with, say, 2 points per dollar. It records a liability for those points. On paper, the bank now “owes” you something. In reality, it owes you the chance to redeem later, under rules it can change with notice.
3. Issuer → Airline/Hotel (When You Transfer or Redeem Co-brand): If you move points to, say, an airline, the bank pays that airline cash for the miles at a wholesale rate. The airline books deferred revenue and a mileage liability. Your points morph into their miles - new label, same IOU.
4. Airline/Hotel → You (When You Redeem): Someday you trade those miles for a seat or room. The airline recognizes revenue and extinguishes the liability. The hard cost is the marginal seat or room that otherwise might have flown or sat empty. If you redeem at peak times, they built a price wall. If you’re clever, you bring that wall down.
5. Revolvers → Issuers (Interest): While you’re playing wizard with transfer charts, a different customer pays interest on last month’s steak dinner. That APR is not a rounding error; it’s the engine. Transactors (people who pay in full) get rewarded. Revolvers (people who don’t) subsidize the party.

Everyone is getting something, and no one is admitting who pays.

Spoiler: the merchant pays first. The revolver pays last.

Why It Looks Like a Ponzi (But Isn’t)

A pure Ponzi takes money from new participants to pay impossible promises owed to earlier ones. Here, the “new money” is very much real: merchant fees clear instantly, and interest revenue clears monthly. The “promises” are flexible, and that flexibility is everything.

The airlines and hotels did the jiu-jitsu move of the century: they alchemized loyalty into a wholesale commodity, then sold it to banks by the truckload. The banks happily buy because they can issue you points today and nudge the actual cost of your redemption into a future quarter - often at a discount, sometimes never.

That “sometimes never” has a name.

Pillar One: Breakage (The Quietest Profit in Marketing)

Breakage is the polite accounting term for points that are issued but never redeemed. Breakage happens for a dozen boring reasons: people forget, they move, they lose access to a program, balances expire, or they redeem for low-value options that cost the issuer less than the headline value implies.

Think of breakage like unclaimed gift cards. Your drawer at home is their quarterly earnings beat.

Even when points don’t expire, breakage persists. Tiny balances are stranded. A million micro-inefficiencies accumulate into millions of dollars in profit. Programs even model expected breakage and recognize revenue from it. The machine counts on human nature: good intentions without follow-through. That alone makes a universal run on redemptions statistically impossible.

Pillar Two: Inflation (Devalue Early, Devalue Often)

Points are not money. They are a corporate scrip with a floating exchange rate controlled by the issuer. That’s the inflation lever.

When a program “re-prices” an award chart or introduces “dynamic pricing,” they quietly change the exchange rate. Your 60,000-mile Europe business class fantasy becomes 90,000, then “from 90,000,” then “varies by demand.” That isn’t theft; it’s policy. It gives loyalty teams the ability to:

• Match liability to revenue when travel booms or slumps.
• Nudge redemptions to off-peak dates and B-routes.
• Stretch the outstanding pool of miles across a larger calendar without adding planes or rooms.

Inflation is not a bug. It is basic hygiene for programs that sell billions of dollars of points every year. As long as they keep headline “sweet spots” alive to generate blog posts and YouTube thumbnails, customers believe.

Pillar Three: Liability Timing (Float, Optionality, and the Interest of Time)

Banks and travel companies hold your points as liabilities. But those liabilities don’t behave like payroll. They behave like soft promises with long fuses. This time lag creates three gifts:

Float: They collect cash now (merchant fees, miles sold to issuers) and deliver value later. In finance, the time value of money is not a slogan. It’s the whole game.

Optionality: Programs choose when and how to release award space. Banks choose which transfer partners to discount this month. Optionality is worth real money because it lets them steer demand when it suits operations.

Smoothing: Because redemptions dribble in over years, programs can manage inventory, devalue in micro-steps, and adjust partner contracts with minimal shock. The liability becomes a slow-moving river, not a tidal wave.

This is how the machine stays upright while looking precarious from the sidewalk.

The Paradox of Points

Points are worthless until you redeem them. And priceless if you redeem them well.

That paradox explains the psychology of the hobby. The spreadsheet says, “These aren’t dollars.” Your Instagram says, “Santorini, baby.” The truth lives in the friction between those realities. Points earn emotional yield, not just financial yield. They turn Tuesday-night grocery runs into business-class upgrades. They reward planning, patience, and a tolerance for fine print.

This is why the best players hoard with purpose and burn with precision. They treat points like perishable fruit, not like bonds. They don’t let balances swell into a target the program can devalue. They let the liability sit on someone else’s books for as little time as possible.

Thought Experiment: What If Everyone Redeemed Tomorrow?

Pretend every point-holder woke up and tried to cash out for maximum value on the same day. What happens?

1. Award Space Vanishes: Airlines don’t publish unlimited saver seats. Hotels don’t release every room for points. The visible inventory dries up in minutes and is replaced with dynamic prices that spike under demand.
2. Redemption Prices Surge: Programs push “from” rates upward or deploy demand-based charts that double or triple under load. Your “sweet spot” turns into “sorry, not today.”
3. IT Rate-Limiting: Websites throttle, queues form, phone lines melt. Caps on transfers, daily limits, and anti-abuse triggers kick in. Systems designed for normal traffic defend themselves.
4. Program Rule Shields: Each program’s T&Cs give it broad latitude to adjust, limit, or cancel redemptions in extraordinary circumstances. They wrote their own emergency brakes.
5. Real-World Capacity: Even if pricing didn’t spike, there aren’t enough premium seats or upgraded rooms to absorb a universal run. Capacity is finite by design.

So no, the system wouldn’t “collapse.” It would shrug, harden, and ration. The outcome would be annoyance, not insolvency. And by the time the mob cooled down, inflation would quietly reset the board.

Why the Run Never Happens

The thought experiment is entertaining, but human behavior makes it academic.

• Most customers don’t optimize. They take 0.6–1.0 cents per point for gift cards or statement credits because it’s easy. That’s a dream for issuers relative to the wholesale price they paid for those points.
• Balances are fragmented. People collect across multiple programs with low-to-mid balances that never consolidate into a headline redemption.
• Life intrudes. Job changes, moves, babies, and recessions interrupt hobby time. Breakage rises. Opportunistic devaluations slide by unnoticed.
• Aspirations differ. Not everyone is chasing Qsuites or Park Hyatt. Many are thrilled with domestic economy flights and mid-tier hotel nights. Demand spreads out.
• Rules gate redemptions. Transfer delays, account verification, fuel surcharges, and blackout dates create natural speed bumps.
• Fear of missing out flips to fear of wasting. People hoard for a dream trip that never quite lands. Programs count on that hoarding to keep liabilities tame.

The result is a population that earns faster than it burns and accepts that some value will evaporate. That’s the business model, not the risk factor.

Who Pays (Short Answer: Not You, If You’re Careful)

If you pay in full and treat points like a coupon with a brain, the math tilts in your favor.

Merchants Pay: Interchange and assessments skim a slice of every sale. In effect, the rewards hobby taxes businesses. They respond by raising prices a hair across the board. Non-card users and small-margin merchants quietly subsidize the premium-card crowd.

Revolvers Pay: Interest revenue is the sun around which this galaxy spins. The bank can afford to throw you a 100,000-point bonus because a meaningful fraction of the portfolio will carry balances, pay interest, and cough up late fees. The dark side funds the sparkle.

You Pay (… if you get sloppy): Miss a payment, carry a balance, or chase a bonus you don’t need, and the APR wipes out a year of wins in a single statement. Game over. The system counts on a portion of smart people having one dumb month.

Why Airlines and Hotels Love This More Than Flying and Sleeping

Airlines and hotels sell miles and points to banks at scale. That revenue is high-margin and low-complaint compared to running a global network of planes, crews, unions, maintenance, and fuel. Points behave like digital inventory with almost no storage cost. When you redeem, the company fills a seat or room whose incremental cost may be low. When you don’t redeem, they booked profit upfront and carry a liability that often gets devalued into compliance.

This is why programs keep the carousel moving with promos, partnerships, and “flash sales.” They want you engaged enough to keep earning, not so empowered that you drain the liability quickly at peak value. The sweet spot must be just sweet enough.

The Mechanics That Keep You Playing

Anchoring: “Business class is $5,000 cash or 80,000 miles.” Your brain hears, “My 80,000 miles are worth $5,000.” No, they were worth $5,000 on that day, for that route, under those rules. Tomorrow the anchor moves.

Gamification: Tiers, badges, progress bars, and elite challenges turn accounting into a video game. Humans lose rationality near 90% completion. Programs know.

Scarcity Theater: Limited award space creates urgency. Add a countdown timer and “2 left at this price,” and you’ll forgive a devaluation you would rage about in a vacuum.

Sunk Costs: Once you’ve chosen a program and earned status, it hurts to switch - even as value erodes. The leash is velvet, but it’s still a leash.

How to Play the “Ponzi” Without Becoming the Mark

If you’re going to swim with sharks, bring a cage. UpNonStop rules of engagement:

Never pay interest. Not once, not for a day. Set autopay to statement balance. If cash flow is tight, cool it with the churn.

Earn with a plan to burn. Don’t hoard for hoarding’s sake. Identify 2–3 target redemptions and build toward them. Burn when ready. Rinse and pivot.

Prefer flexible currencies. Bank points that transfer keep your options open when a program devalues. Flexibility is an antidote to inflation.

Know your floor. Decide the minimum cent-per-point value you’ll accept. If a redemption falls below your floor, pay cash and save the points for a better yield.

Diversify partners and routes. Don’t marry a single airline or alliance. Inventory is a liquidity problem; solve it with alternatives.

Redeem for experiences, not trinkets. Gift cards and statement credits are the fast-food of loyalty. The calories are empty. Aim higher.

Audit your balances quarterly. Small, consistent moves beat heroic rescues. Transfer bonuses and off-peak windows favor the organized.

Watch for death-by-fees. Some awards come with surcharges that quietly erase your value. Price the whole trip, not just the mileage.

Exit gracefully. If a program guts its chart or plays games with space, pivot. Loyalty should be earned both ways.

The Inevitable Squeeze (and Why It Won’t Kill the Game)

Will rewards get stingier over time? Of course. Margins compress, regulators glare, and fintech competition lowers interchange in some markets. Programs adapt by:

Adding tiers that promise “more control” (read: priority access to the same shrinking pool).

Shifting to dynamic pricing that obscures devaluations inside demand-based math.

Promoting co-brands where they control both earn and burn (and keep more economics).

Leaning on partnerships that create new earn outlets (rideshare, dining, grocery) to replace old ones.

The net effect is a treadmill. Your earning options look richer even as high-value redemptions require more work. That’s fine. The game was never about easy; it was about asymmetry. If you read the rules, you get outsized experiences for pedestrian spend. If you don’t, you fund someone else’s champagne.

The Merchant’s Quiet Revolt

You’ve seen the “cash discount” at gas stations and mom-and-pop pizza joints. You’ve seen businesses steer to debit or charge a “technology fee.” That’s the pressure valve. Enterprise merchants negotiate fees down, raise prices a hair, bury costs in the menu, or build private-label ecosystems. None of that stops the tide. Consumers like points. Businesses like fewer charge